本研究主要目的是評估職業安全與衛生管理證照的市場價值。我們利用需求面、供給面及中介平台面作為研究架構中三個主準則，然後透過文獻回顧及腦力激盪法，選擇出十個次準則及五個方案。接著，本研究採用多準則決策分析方法，如模糊層級分析法(fuzzy analytic hierarchy process)、模糊網路層級分析法(fuzzy analytic network process, FANP)及折衷排序法(VlseKriterijumska Optimizacija I Kompromisno Resenje, VIKOR)作為證照市場價值的評估分析工具。質化分析結果顯示：在三個主準則方面，需求面遠較供給面及中介平台面重要；在次準則方面，供給面中的“證照與市場契合度”及中介平台面中的“政府政策與法規”最為重要，而需求面中的“自我肯定”則是專家認為最不重要的次準則。最後，透過方案的排序，我們得到在職業安全與衛生管理證照領域中，“甲級職業衛生技術士”、 “甲級職業安全技術士”及 “高考工業安全技師”是最具有市場價值的證照。
希望本研究的分析結果，可以幫助產業界、政府、考生及其他與此領域相關的
團體找到影響職業安全與衛生管理證照供需的因素。

The purpose of this study is to evaluate the market value of certificates for occupational safety and health management in Taiwan. To construct the framework, we utilize Demand, Supply and an Intermediary unit as the three main criteria in this study. In addition, ten sub-criteria and five alternatives are chosen through a literature review and brainstorming, respectively. The study utilizes Multi-Criteria Decision Making methods, such as Fuzzy AHP, Fuzzy ANP and VIKOR as the tools for evaluating and analyzing the market value of the certificates. The qualitative analysis results suggest that the Demand aspect is more important than the Supply and Intermediary unit aspects, that “Fit between certificates and industries” in relation to Supply is the most important
sub-criterion, and that “Government and regulations” for the Intermediary unit has the second highest weight. Furthermore, “Self-affirmation” in regard to Demand is the least important sub-criterion. Finally, “Level A technician for occupational safety management”, “Level A technician for occupational health management” and “Higher examination for industrial safety” have significant market value in Occupational Safety and Health Management.
We use the hybrid FMCDM model in this study to provide help to industries, the
government, examinees and other interested parties to find out the factors affecting the supply of and demand for certificates.

Amiri, M., Zandieh, M., Soltani, R., and Vahdani, B. (2009). A hybrid multi-criteria decision-making model for firms competence evaluation. Expert Systems with Applications, 36(10), 12314-12322.
Aslani, F., Aslani A. (2012). Application of fuzzy AHP approach to selection of organizational structure with consideration to contextual dimensions. Organizacija, 45, 246-254
Arbel, A., and Orgler, Y. E. (1990). An application of the AHP to bank strategic planning: The mergers and acquisitions. European Journal of Operational Research, 48(1), 27-37.
Ayağ, Z., and Özdemir, R. G. (2009). A hybrid approach to concept selection through fuzzy analytic network process. Computers & Industrial Engineering, 56(1), 368-379.
Ayağ, Z., and Özdemir, R. G. (2012). Evaluating machine tool alternatives through modified TOPSIS and alpha-cut based fuzzy ANP. International Journal of Production Economics, 140(2), 630-636.
Baležentis, A., Baležentis, T., and Misiunas, A. (2012). An integrated assessment of Lithuanian economic sectors based on financial ratios and fuzzy MCDM methods. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 18(1), 34-53.
Buckely, J. J. (1985). Fuzzy hierarchical analysis. Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 17(3), 233-247.
Büyüközkan, G., Feyzioglu, O., and Ç ifçi, G. (2011). Fuzzy multi-criteria evaluation of knowledge management tools. International Journal of Computational Intelligence Systems, 4(2), 184-195.
Büyüközkan, G., and Ç ifçi, G. (2012). A novel hybrid MCDM approach based on fuzzy DEMATEL, fuzzy ANP and fuzzy TOPSIS to evaluate green suppliers. Expert Systems with Applications, 39(3), 3000-3011.
Carnevale, A. P., Gainer, L. J., & Meltzer, A. S. (1981). Workplace basics: The skills employers want.
Carnevale, A. P., Porro, J. D. (1994). Quality education: School reform for the new American economy.
Cebeci, U. (2009). Fuzzy AHP-based decision support system for selecting ERP systems in textile industry by using balanced scorecard. Expert Systems with Applications, 36(5), 8900-8909.
Chan, F. T. S., and Kumar, N. (2007). Global supplier development considering risk factors using fuzzy extended AHP-based approach. Omega, 35(4), 417-431.
Chan, F. T. S., Chan, H. K., Chan, M. H., and Humphreys, P. K. (2006). An integrated fuzzy approach for the selection of manufacturing technologies. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 27(7-8), 747-758.
Chan, F. T. S., Chan, H. K., Lau, H. C. W., & Ip, R. W. L. (2006). An AHP approach in benchmarking logistics performance of the postal industry. Benchmarking: An International Journal, 13(6), 636-661.
Chang, C. (2008). Research of manpower needs and training category of Taiwan's logistics industry.
Chang, C. H. (1997). Application the Fuzzy Set Theory to the Credit Rating Table Improvement for the Medium and Small Business Loan Process by the Bank.
Chang, D. Y. (1996). Applications of the extent analysis method on fuzzy AHP. European Journal of Operational Research, 95(3), 649-655.
Chang, S. C., and Tsai, P. H. (2015). A hybrid financial performance evaluation model for wealth management banks following the global financial crisis. Technological and Economic Development of Economy. In Press
Chen, M. F., Tzeng, G. H., and Tang, T. I. (2005). Fuzzy MCDM approach for evaluation of expatriate assignments. International Journal of Information Technology & Decision Making, 4(2), 277-296.
Chen, H. S., Wang, P. W., Chen, C. M., and Lee, H. T. (2010b). An analytic hierarchy process approach with linguistic variables for selection of an R&D strategic alliance partner. Computers & Industrial Engineering, 58(2), 278-287.
Chen, F. H., Hsu, T. S., and Tzeng, G. H. (2011). A balanced scorecard approach to establish a performance evaluation and relationship model for hot spring hotels based on a hybrid MCDM model combining DEMATEL and ANP. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 30(4), 908-932.
Chen, C. H., Shen, C. Y., and Lin, J. Y. (2010). Studies of the industry required certificates for industrial management students admitted.
Chen, J. K., and Chen, I. S. (2012). A network hierarchical feedback system for Taiwanese universities based on the integration of total quality management and innovation. Applied Soft Computing, 12(8), 2394-2408.
Cheng, L. C. (2009). The C Level problems for vocational school students. Taipei Country Education, 66, 78-80.
Chiu, W. Y., Tzeng, G. H., and Li, H. L. (2013). A new hybrid MCDM model combining DANP with VIKOR to improve e-store business. Knowledge-Based Systems, 37,48-61.
Chou, W. C., and Cheng, Y. P. (2012). A hybrid fuzz MCDM approach for evaluating website quality of professional accounting firms. Expert Systems with Applications, 39(3), 2783-2793.
Chou, Y., Lee, C., and Chung, J. (2004). Understanding M-commerce payment systems through the analytic hierarchy process. Journal of Business Research, 57(12), 1423-1430.
Corbell, G.L. (2006), The need for Certification of the Safety Professional. Professional Safety, 51(3) , 60-64.
Council of Labor Affairs (2004). The thirtieth anniversary of the statistics.
Csutora, R., and Buckley, J.J. (2001), Fuzzy hierarchical analysis: the Lambda-Max method, Fuzzy Sets and Systems, Vol. 120, pp. 181-195.
Dagdeviren, M. Yuksel, I., and Kurt, M. (2008). A fuzzy analytic network process (ANP) model to identify faulty behavior risk (FBR) in work system. Safety Science, 46(5),771-783.
Dalalah, D., Faris AL-Oqla, and Hayajneh, M. (2010) Application of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) in multi-criteria analysis of the selection of cranes. Jordan Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, 4, 567-578.
Deng, H. (1999). Multi criteria analysis with fuzzy pair-wise comparison. International Journal of Approximate Reasoning, 21(3), 215-231.
Ebrahimnejad, S., Mousavi, S. M., Tavakkoli-Moghaddam, R., Hashemi, H., and Vahdani, B. (2012). A novel two-phase group decision making approach for construction project selection in a fuzzy environment. Applied Mathematical Modelling, 36(9), 4197-4217.
Fouladgar, M. M., Yazdani-Chamzini, A., Zavadskas, E. K., and Haji Moini, S. H. (2012). A new hybrid model for evaluating the working strategies: Case study of construction company. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 18(1), 164-188.
Fu, H. P., Chu, K. K., Chao, P., Lee, H. H., and Liao, Y. C. (2011). Using fuzzy AHP and VIKOR for benchmarking analysis in the hotel industry. Service Industries Journal, 31(14), 2373-2389.
Ghassemi, S. A., and Danesh, S. (2013). A hybrid fuzzy multi-criteria decision making approach for desalination process selection. Desalination, 313, 44-50.
Ginevičius, R., Krivka, A., and Šimkūnaite, J. (2010). The model of forming competitive strategy of an enterprise under the conditions of an oligopolistic market. Journal of Business Economics and Management, 11(3), 367-395.
Gumus, A. T. (2009). Evaluation of hazardous waste transportation firms by using a two step fuzzy-AHP and TOPSIS methodology. Expert Systems with Applications, 36(2), 4067-4074.
Herrera, F., and Herrera-Viedma, E. (2000). Linguistic decision analysis: Steps for solving decision problems under linguistic information. Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 115(1), 67-82.
Hsia, H. L. (2014). A study on Correlation between the Factors of Skill Test and Career Development.
Hsu, C. H., Wang, F. K., and Tzeng, G. H. (2012). The best vendor selection for conducting the recycled material based on a hybrid MCDM model combining DANP with VIKOR. Resource, Conservation and Recycling, 66, 95-111.
Hsu, M. H. (2002). A study on the reform of Taiwan’s skill test system.
Huang, J. J., Tzeng, G. H., and Ong, C. S. (2005). Multidimensional data in multidimensional scaling using the analytic network process. Pattern Recognition Letters, 26(6), 755-767.
Hung, C. H. (2009). Quantitative and qualitative change of skill test.
Javalgi, R. G., Armacost, R. L., Hosseini, J. C. (1989). Using the analytic hierarchy process for bank management: Analysis of consumer bank selection decisions. Journal of Business Research, 19(1), 33-49.
Jung, U., and Seo, D. W. (2010). An ANP approach for R&D project evaluation based on
interdependences between research objective and evaluation criteria. Decision Support Systems, 49(3), 335-342.
Kahraman, C., Ruan, D., and Dogan, Y. (2003). Fuzzy group decision-making for facility location selection. Information Sciences, 157, 135-153.
Kang, T.H., Tzeng, G.H., Yuan, Benjamin and Lee, H.Y. (2003), MCDM Approach for Selecting the Performance of Outsourced ERP Systems in the IC Design Industry in Taiwan. Proceedings of the Fourth Annual Global Information Technology Management World Conference, 6-9.
Kannan, V. (2010). Benchmarking the service quality of ocean container carriers using AHP. Benchmarking: An International Journal, 17(5), 637-656.
Kleiner, M. M., Krueger, A. B. (2011). Analyzing the extent and influence of occupational licensing on the labor market.
Lee, C. C., Tzeng, G. H., Chiang, C. (2011). Determining service quality measurement key indicators in a travel website using a fuzzy analytical hierarchy process. International Journal of Electronic Business Management, 9(4), 322-333.
Lee, C. Y., Lee, H. Y., Seol, H. N., and Park, Y. T. (2011c). Evaluation of new service concepts using rough set theory and group analytic hierarchy process. Expert Systems with Applications, 39(3), 3404-3412.
Lee, J. W., and Kim, S. H. (2000). Using analytic network process and goal programming for interdependent information system project selection. Computers & Operations Research, 27(4), 367-382.
Lee, L. S., Lee, H. D., and Chen, S. J. (2010). Retrospect and Prospect of Certification System in Taiwan’s Technological and Vocational Education. Journal of Educational Resources and Research, 93, 31-52.
Leung, L. C., and Cao, D. (2000). On consistency and ranking of alternatives in fuzzy AHP. European Journal of Operational Research, 124(1), 102-113.
Lin, C. W. (2003). A study on cognition of professional certificate system for workers in the life insurance industry.
Lin, D. S. (2011). Linkage between Education and the Labor Market: Analysis of Market Value of Professional Certificates in Taiwan. Review of Social Sciences, 5(1),40-83.
Lin, J. H., Tzeng, G. H., and Jen, W.L. (2005). Utilizing VIKOR to Make ERP System Supplier Selection Decision. Agriculture and Economics, 34, 69-90
Lin, H. Y., Hsu, P. Y., and Sheen, G. J. (2007). A fuzzy-based decision-making procedure for data warehouse system selection. Expert Systems with Applications,32(3), 939-953.
Lin, H. F. (2010a). An application of fuzzy AHP for evaluating course website quality. Computers & Education, 54(4), 877-888.
Lin, L. Z., Huang, L. C., and Yeh, H. R. (2012). Fuzzy group decision-making for service innovations in quality function deployment. Group Decision and Negotiation, 21(4), 495-517.
Liao, C. W., Kuan, C. Y., Chang, Y. C., and Chen, C. H. (2012). A study on factors affecting skill test participation for students. Yu Da Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, 8, 263-269.
Liao, C. H. (2004). The Correlation between Professional Competitiveness and Certification Examination for Certified Technicians.
Liou, J. J. H., Tzeng, G. H., Tsai, C. Y., and Hsu, C. C. (2011). A hybrid ANP model in fuzzy environments for strategic alliance partner selection in the airline industry. Applied Soft Computing, 11(4), 3515-3524.
Liou, J. J. H., and Tzeng, G. H. (2012). Comments on “multiple criteria decision making (MCDM) methods in economics: An overview”. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 18(4), 672-695.
Liu, H. C., and Huang, C. C. (2012). A study on using fuzzy sets in a young men and women matching system. Journal of Science and Engineering Technology, 8(1),21-32.
Liu, H. T., and Tsai, Y. L. (2012). A fuzzy risk assessment approach for occupational hazards in the construction industry. Safety Science, 50(4), 1067-1078.
Liu, W. U., Chen, S. C., Hsiao, C. Y., Hu, Y. T., and You, C. T. (2013). On relationships among hospitality employees’ viewpoints on certifications, number of certifications, and salaries: The case of the hotel industry in the northern region of Taiwan. Journal of Sport, Leisure and Hospital Research, 8(4), 77-105
Ma, J., and Zhou, D. (2000). Fuzzy set approach to the assessment of student-centered learning. IEEE Transactions on Education, 40(2), 237-241
Meade, L. M., and Sarkis, J. (1999). Analyzing organizational project alternatives for agile manufacturing processes – An analytical network approach. International Journal of Production Research, 37(2), 241-261.
Merritt, D. (1996). A conceptual framework for industry-based skill standards. Centerfocus.
Mikhailov, L. (2004). A fuzzy approach to deriving priorities from interval pair-wise comparison judgments. European Journal of Operational Research, 159(3),687-704.
Nguyen, H. L., Fong, C. M., & Ho, C. T. (2010). Using the analytical hierarchy process in decision analysis—The case of the Vietnam State Securities Commission.
Opricovic, S. (1998). Multicriteria optimization of civil engineering systems: Faculty of Civil Engineering. Belgrade.
Opricovic, S., and Tzeng, G. H. (2004). Compromise solution by MCDM methods: A comparative analysis of VIKOR and TOPSIS. European Journal of Operational Research, 156(2), 445-455.
Opricovic, S. (2011). Fuzzy VIKOR with an application to water resources planning. Expert Systems with Applications, 38(10), 12983-12990.
Peng, T. L. (1993). Implementation and impact of skill test and vocational certificate system. Journal of Technological and Vocational Education, 17, 7-12.
Peng, Y., Kou, G., Wang, G., and Shi, Y. (2011). FAMCDM: A fusion approach of MCDM methods to rank multiclass classification algorithms. Omega, 39(6),677-689.
Saaty, T. L. (1980). The analytic hierarchy process. McGraw Hill Publications.
Saaty, T. L. (1990). How to make a decision: The analytic hierarchy process. European Journal of Operational Research, 48(1), 9-26.
Saaty, T.L. (1994) How to make a decision: the analytic hierarchy process, Interfaces, 6, 19-43.
Saaty, T. L. (1994b). Fundamentals of decision making and priority theory with the analytic hierarchy process. Pittsburgh, PA:RWS Publications.
Saaty, T. L. (1996). Decision making with dependence and feedback: The analytic network process. RWS Publications Pittsburgh.
Saaty, T. L. (1999). Fundamentals of the analytic network process. Kobe, Japan: ISAHP.
Saaty, T. L., and Ö zdemir, M. (2003). Negative priorities in the analytic hierarchy process. Mathematical and Computer Modelling, 37(9), 1063-1075.
Saaty, T. L. (2008). Decision making with the analytic hierarchy process. Services Sciences, 1(1), 83-98
Salem, M. S. M. and Fantazy K. A., (2014) The use of the analytic hierarchy process in the determination of earning quality: The case of UAE. Journal of Modern Accounting and Auditing, 10(3), 308-326
Sarkis, J. (2003). Quantitative models for performance measurement systems – alternate considerations. International Journal of Production Economics, 86(1), 81-90.
Seçme, N. Y., Bayrakdaroğlu, A., and Kahraman, C. (2009). Fuzzy performance evaluation in the Turkish banking sector using the analytic hierarchy process and TOPSIS. Expert Systems with Applications, 36(9), 11699-11709.
Sevkli, M., Oztekin, A., Uysal, O., Torlak, G., Turkyilmaz, A., and Delen D. (2012). Development of a fuzzy ANP based SWOT analysis for the airline industry in Turkey. Expert Systems with Applications, 39(1), 14-24.
Shen, Y. P. (2003). A study on the application of the fuzzy theory to the total evaluation of student grading.
Sheng, H. P. (2011). A study on the Occupational Effectiveness for Information Technician Certificates from the Viewpoint of Education, Government and Industry.
Sipahi, S., and Timor, M. (2010). The analytic hierarchy process and analytic network process: An overview of applications. Management Decision, 48(5), 775-808.
Stankevičienė, J., and Mencaitė, E. (2012). The evaluation of bank performance using a multicriteria decision making model: A case study on Lithuanian commercial banks. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 18(1), 189-205.
Taslicali, A. K. and Ercan, S. (2006). The analytic hierarchy and the analytic network process in multicriteria decision making: A comparative study. Journal of Aeronautics and Space Technologies, 2(4), 55-65.
Teng, J. Y. and Tzeng, G. H. (1989). Connotation characteristics and application of AHP. Journal of the Chinese Statistical Association, 27(7), 1-20.
Thoedtida T. and Thongpoon. (2013). An Integrated VIKOR and Fuzzy AHP Method for assessing a sustainable research project. World Applied Sciences Journal, 22(12), 1729-1738.
Tsai, P. H., and Chang, S. C. (2014). Comparing the Apple iPad and non-Apple camp tablet PCs: A multicriteria decision analysis. Technological and Economic Development of Economy. 20(1), 285-313.
Tsai, P. H. (2014). Constructing an evaluation model for Tablet PCs and Taiwan’s E-book firms: A hybrid fuzzy multiple criteria decision making approach.
Tung, S. L., and Tang, S. L. (1998). A comparison of the Saaty’s AHP and modified AHP for right and left eigenvector inconsistency. European Journal of Operational Research, 106(1), 123-128.
Tzeng, G. H., Teng, M. H., Chen, J. J., and Opricovic, S. (2002). Multicriteria selection for a restaurant location in Taipei. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 21(2), 171-187.
Vaidya, O. S., and Kumar, S. (2006). Analytic hierarchy process: An overview of applications. European Journal of Operational Research, 169(1), 1-29.
Wu, C. R., Lin, C. T., and Tsai, P. H. (2009). Analysing alternatives in financial services for wealth management banks: The analytic network process and the balanced scorecard. IMA Journal of Management Mathematics, 20(3), 303-321.
Wu, H. Y., Lin, Y. K., and Chang, C. H. (2011). Performance evaluation of extension education centers in universities based on the balanced scorecard. Evaluation and Program Planning, 34(1), 37-50.
Wu, S. P. (2008). Improvement and new policies of skill tests. Taiwan Labor. Quarterly publication.14, 99-105.
Wu, T. C. (2012) The research of relationship between learning background of labor safety health management and business unit safety health performance, that safety health management ability plays the intervening variable.
Xin, B. L. and Chiang, C. Y. (2011). Analysis of the impact of the income of professional licenses. T＆D Fashion, 124
Yalcin, N., Bayrakdaroglu, A., and Kahraman, C. (2012). Application of fuzzy multi-criteria decision making methods for financial performance evaluation of Turkish manufacturing industries. Expert Systems with Applications, 39(1), 350-364.
Yang, H. W., and Chang, K. F. (2012). Combining means-end chain and fuzzy ANP to explore customers’ decision process in selecting bundies. International Journal of Information Management, 32(4), 381-395.
Yüksel, İ., and Dağdeviren, M. (2010). Using the fuzzy analytic network process (ANP) for Balanced Scorecard (BSC): A case study for a manufacturing firm. Expert Systems with Applications, 37(2), 1270-1278.
Zadeh, L. A. (1965). Fuzzy sets. Information and Control, 8(3), 338-353.
Zadeh, L. A. (1975). The concept of a linguistic variable and its application to approximate reasoning, Parts 1-3. Information Sciences, 8(3), 199-249, 301-357; 9(1), 43-80.
Zavadskas, E. K., and Kaklauskas, A. (1996). Determination of an efficient contractor by using the new method of multicriteria assessment, in Langford, D. A.; Retik, A. (Eds.). International Symposium for “The Organisation and Management of Construction”. Shaping Theory and Practice. Vol. 2. Managing the Construction Project and Managing Risk. CIB W65. London, Weinheim, New York, Tokyo,
Melbourne, Madras. London: E and FN SPON, 94-104.
Zavadaskas, E. K., Turskis, Z., Tamosaitiene, J., and Marina, V. (2008). Multicriteria selection of project managers by applying grey criteria. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 14(4), 462-477.
Zavadskas, E. K., and Turskis, Z. (2011). Multiple criteria decision making (MCDM) methods in economics: An overview. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 17(2), 397-427.
Zimmermann, H. J. (1991). Fuzzy Set Theory and its Applications. Boston: Kluwer Academic.