The next generation access networks are meeting wire line and wireless services. To offer the end users more choices and greater suitability, it is desirable to provide high speed connection to serve the fixed and mobile costumers with high capacity, large bandwidth, and good signal, for the radio over fiber system.
Actually, two types of modulation techniques are used in analog radio over fiber system. The direct modulation technique, which is easy to demonstrate and has a low cost. But, it cannot provide a high gain because of the laser limitation. On the other hand, external modulation laser, which operates in continuous wave mode. This method can provide a high gain. But, it is complex and expensive.
This thesis makes a comparison between the direct and external modulation for radio over fiber application. The advantages and disadvantages for both types of modulation techniques are discussed with respect to the following parameters: gain, maximum radio frequency input power, and the power budget. It also introduces some definitions and assumptions in brief. Furthermore, it proposes some techniques which can improve the link performance.
From the link performance analysis we found that the good EVM value for direct modulation is obtain in the RF input power range of -1.4 dBm to 13.6 dBm, unlike external modulation which ranges between to -7.4 and 4.6 dBm.
In the case of external modulation, the increasing in optical input will decrease the RF input power and at the same time will increase the RF output band power range; as a result, we conclude that direct modulation is suitable for the downstream architecture which needs a higher RF input power to transfer the data. While, external modulation can be used for the upstream architecture, since it needs a high optical input power to transfer the data from the users to the base station.
We found that under the maximum conversion efficiency condition the RF loss is far better for direct modulation than external modulation, in terms of PD optical input power and the RF input power.
Measuring the power budget for the RoF links with a splitter of 2, 4, 8, 16, and 32 splitting ratio, the external modulation can achieve a 4 dBm gain at 100 mW optical power with using EDFA in the system, unlike the direct modulation which can obtain -11 dBm loss under the same condition.
Measuring the spurious – free dynamic range for RoF link shows that the external modulation of 119 dB. Hz^(3⁄2) has a better linearity than the direct modulation (79.81dB. Hz^(3⁄2)).

The next generation access networks are meeting wire line and wireless services. To offer the end users more choices and greater suitability, it is desirable to provide high speed connection to serve the fixed and mobile costumers with high capacity, large bandwidth, and good signal, for the radio over fiber system.
Actually, two types of modulation techniques are used in analog radio over fiber system. The direct modulation technique, which is easy to demonstrate and has a low cost. But, it cannot provide a high gain because of the laser limitation. On the other hand, external modulation laser, which operates in continuous wave mode. This method can provide a high gain. But, it is complex and expensive.
This thesis makes a comparison between the direct and external modulation for radio over fiber application. The advantages and disadvantages for both types of modulation techniques are discussed with respect to the following parameters: gain, maximum radio frequency input power, and the power budget. It also introduces some definitions and assumptions in brief. Furthermore, it proposes some techniques which can improve the link performance.
From the link performance analysis we found that the good EVM value for direct modulation is obtain in the RF input power range of -1.4 dBm to 13.6 dBm, unlike external modulation which ranges between to -7.4 and 4.6 dBm.
In the case of external modulation, the increasing in optical input will decrease the RF input power and at the same time will increase the RF output band power range; as a result, we conclude that direct modulation is suitable for the downstream architecture which needs a higher RF input power to transfer the data. While, external modulation can be used for the upstream architecture, since it needs a high optical input power to transfer the data from the users to the base station.
We found that under the maximum conversion efficiency condition the RF loss is far better for direct modulation than external modulation, in terms of PD optical input power and the RF input power.
Measuring the power budget for the RoF links with a splitter of 2, 4, 8, 16, and 32 splitting ratio, the external modulation can achieve a 4 dBm gain at 100 mW optical power with using EDFA in the system, unlike the direct modulation which can obtain -11 dBm loss under the same condition.
Measuring the spurious – free dynamic range for RoF link shows that the external modulation of 119 dB. Hz^(3⁄2) has a better linearity than the direct modulation (79.81dB. Hz^(3⁄2)).

[1] H. Chen and Nanjing, Development of an 80 Gbit/s InP-based Mach-Zehnder Modulator, Doctoral Dissertation, Berlin, 2007.
[2] A. Kumar, Studies on optical components and radio over fiber system, Bachelor Thesis, Orissa, 2009.
[3] M. S. Rahman, J. H. Lee, Y. Park, and K. Ki-Doo, “Radio over fiber as a cost effective technology for transmission of wimax signals”, Journal of World Academy of Science, Enginnering and Technology, vol 56, pp. 424-428, 2009.
[4] G. P. Agrawal, Fiber-Optic Communication Systems, 3rd Ed., Wiley, New York, 2002.
[5] C.H. Cox, E.I. Ackerman, G.E. Betts, J.L. Prince, "Limits on the performance of RF-over-fiber links and their impact on device design", Microwave Theory and Techniques, IEEE Transactions on , vol.54, no.2, pp. 906- 920, Feb. 2006.
[6] A.H. Gnauck, T.E. Darcie, G.E. Bodeep, "Comparison of direct and external modulation for CATV lightwave transmission at 1.5 mu m wavelength", Electronics Letters, vol.28, no.20, pp.1875-1876, 24 Sept. 1992.
[7] K.J. Williams, L.T. Nichols, R.D. Esman, "Externally-modulated 3 GHz fibre optic link utilising high current and balanced detection", Electronics Letters , vol.33, no.15, pp.1327-1328, 17 Jul 1997.
[8] X. Zhang, D. Li, Y.Chen, L. Liao, Z. Dong, "Research on drive and control technology of external modulated DFB laser diode", 2009, 9th International Conference on Electronic Measurement & Instruments ICEMI 09, pp.3-961-3-965, 16-19 Aug. 2009.
[9] J.N. Walpole, J.P. Donnelly, P.J. Taylor, L.J. Missaggia, C.T. Harris, R.J. Bailey, A. Napoleone, S.H. Groves, S.R. Chinn, R. Huang, J. Plant, "Slab-coupled 1.3-μm semiconductor laser with single-spatial large-diameter mode", Photonics Technology Letters, IEEE , vol.14, no.6, pp.756-758, June 2002.
[10] C.H. Cox, H. V. Roussell, R. J. Ram, R.J. Helkey, "Broadband, directly modulated analog fiber link with positive intrinsic gain and reduced noise Figure”, 1998, International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, MWP 98, pp.157-160, 12-14 Oct 1998.
[11] J.T. Getty, L.A. Johansson, E.J. Skogen, L.A. Coldren,"1.55-μm bipolar cascade segmented ridge lasers", Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, IEEE Journal of , vol.9, no.5, pp. 1138- 1145, Sept.-Oct. 2003.
[12] C.H. Cox, Analog Optical Links, Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge Univ. Press, 2004.
[13] D. Maack, “Reliability of lithium niobate Mach Zehnder modulators for digital optical fiber telecommunication systems”, SPIE Crit. Rev., CR 73, pp. 197–230, 1999.
[14] G.E. Betts, L.M. Johnson, C.H. Cox, “High-sensitivity lumped-element bandpass modulators in LiNbO3", Lightwave Technology, Journal of , vol.7, no.12, pp.2078-2083, Dec 1989.
[15] K. Noguchi, O. Mitomi, H. Miyazawa, "Millimeter-wave Ti:LiNbO3 optical modulators", Lightwave Technology, Journal of , vol.16, no.4, pp.615-619, Apr 1998.
[16] M. Sugiyama, M. Doi, S. Taniguchi, T. Nakazawa, H.Onaka, "Driver-less 40 Gb/s LiNbO3 modulator with sub-1 V drive voltage", 2002, Optical Fiber Communication Conference and Exhibit, OFC 02, pp. FB6-1, 17-22 Mar 2002.
[17] W.K. Burns, M.M. Howerton, R.P. Moeller, A.S. Greenblatt, R.W. McElhanon, "Broad-band reflection traveling-wave LiNbO3 modulator", Photonics Technology Letters, IEEE , vol.10, no.6, pp.805-806, Jun. 1998.
[18] K. Kawano, M. Kohtoku, M. Ueki, T. Ito, S. Kondoh, Y. Noguchi, Y. Hasumi, "Polarisation-insensitive travelling-wave electrode electroabsorption (TW-EA) modulator with bandwidth over 50 GHz and driving voltage less than 2 V", Electronics Letters , vol.33, no.18, pp.1580-1581, 28 Aug. 1997.
[19] Y. Shi, C. Zhang, H. Zhang, J. Bechtel, L. Dalton, B. Robinson, and W. Steier, “Low (sub-1-Volt) halfwave voltage polymeric electro-optic modulators achieved by controlling chromophore shape”, Science7 April 2000 vol. 288, no. 119, pp. 119–122, Apr. 2000.
[20] M. Oh, H. Zhang, C. Zhang, H. Erlig, Y. Chang, B. Tsap, D. Chang, A. Szep, W. Steier, H. Fetterman, and L. Dalton, “Recent advances in electrooptic polymer modulators incorporating highly nonlinear chromophore” IEEE J. Sel. Topics Quantum Electron., vol. 7, no. 5, pp. 826–835, Sep./Oct. 2001.
[21] Y. Chiu, H. Chou, V. Kaman, P. Abraham, and J. Bowers, “High extinction ratio and saturation power traveling-wave electroabsorption modulator”, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 14, no. 6, pp. 792–794, Jun. 2002.
[22] B. Liu, J. Shim, Y. Chiu, A. Keating, J. Piprek, and J. Bowers, “Analog characterization of low-voltage MQW traveling-wave electroabsorption modulators”, J. Lightw. Technol., vol. 21, no. 12, pp. 3011–3019, Dec. 2003.
[23] J. X. Chen, Y. Wu, W. X. Chen, I. Shubin, A. Clawson, W. S. C. Chang, and P. K. L. Yu “High-Power Intrastep Quantum Well Electroabsorption Modulator Using Single-Sided Large Optical Cavity Waveguide”, IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, vol. 16, no. 2, Feb. 2004.
[24] S. William, and C. Chang, RF Photonic Technology in Optical Fiber Link, Cambridge University Press, Chapter 1, 1st edition (2002)
[25] Y. Takahashi, K. Nagano, and Y. Takasaki, “Optical receiver for VHF multichannel video transmission”, IEEE J. Sel. Areas Commun., vol. 8, no. 7, pp. 1382–1386, Sep. 1990.
[26] K. Vahala, M. Newkirk, and T. Chen, “The optical gain lever: A novel gain mechanism in the direct modulation of quantum well semiconductor lasers”, Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 54, pp. 2506–2508, Jun. 1989.
[27] Application note “Spurious Free Dynamic Range”, http://www.fiber-span.com/Application_Note_Spurious%20Free%2 0Dynamic%20Range.pdf.
[28] J. Chen, R. Ram, and R. Helkey, “Linearity and third-order intermodulation distortion in DFB semiconductor lasers”, IEEE J. Quantum Electron., vol. 35, no. 8, pp. 1231–1237, Aug. 1999.
[29] G.E. Betts, C. Cox, K.G. Ray, "20 GHz optical analog link using an external modulator", IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, vol.2, no.12, pp.923-925, Dec. 1990.
[30] D. Baldwin, “Dynamic range measurements comparing DFB laser links to Mach–Zehnder modulator optical links for wide-band microwave transmission” , in Proc. Photon. Syst. Antenna Applicat. Conf., Monterey,CA, 1993, pp. 51–54.
[31] K.J. Williams, L.T. Nichols and R.D. Esman, "Photodetector nonlinearity limitations on a high-dynamic range 3 GHz fiber optic link", Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol.16, no.2, pp.192-199, Feb. 1998.
[32] K. Loi, X. Mei, J. Hodiak, C.Tu, and W. Chang, “38 GHz bandwidth 1.3μm MQW electroabsorption modulator for RF photonics links” , Electronic. Lett. , vol.34, pp. 1018 – 1019, May 1998.
[32] T.E. Darcie, G.E. Bodeep, "Lightwave subcarrier CATV transmission systems", IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol.38, no.5, pp.524-533, May 1990.
[33] I. Djordjevic, W. Ryan, B. Vasic, Coding for Optical Channels, University of Arizona, Tucson, U.S.A. chapter 2, 2010.
[34] V. Alwayn, Optical Network Design and Implementation, Cisco Press, chapter 4, 2004.
[35] J. Cartledge and G. Burley, “The Effect of Laser Chirping on Lightwave System Performance” J. Lightwave Technology, vol. 7, no. 3, pp. 568-573, 1989.
[36] A. Villafranca, J. Lasobras, I. Garces, "Precise characterization of the frequency chirp in directly modulated DFB lasers" , Electron Devices, 2007 Spanish Conference on , pp.173-176, Jan. 31 2007-Feb. 2 2007.
[37] E. Sackinger, Broadband Circuits for Optical Fiber Communication, chapter 7, 2005.
[38] E.I. Ackerman, G.E. Betts, "The role of photonic and electronic gain in the design of analog optical links", 2005, IEEE Conference on Avionics Fiber-Optics and Photonics, pp. 71- 72, 20-22 Sept. 2005.
[39] A. J. Seeds and K. J. Williams, "Microwave Photonics", Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol.24, no.12, pp.4628-4641, Dec. 2006.
[40] T. Chrysikos, G. Georgopoulos and S. Kotsopoulos, "Site-specific validation of ITU indoor path loss model at 2.4 GHz", World of Wireless, Mobile and Multimedia Networks & Workshops, pp.1-6, 15-19 Jun. 2009.
[41] IEEE Standard 802.16 “Approved Draft IEEE Standard for Local and metropolitan area networks Corrigendum to IEEE Standard for Local and Metropolitan Area Networks-Part 16: Air Interface for Fixed Broadband Wireless Access Systems (Incorporated into IEEE Std 802.16e-2005 and IEEE Std 802.16-2004/Cor 1-2005 E)," IEEE Std P802.16/Cor1/D5, 2005.
[42] C. Cox, G.E. Betts, and L.M. Johnson, "An analytic and experimental comparison of direct and external modulation in analog fiber-optic links", IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol.38, no.5, pp.501-509, May. 1990.
[43] S.Y. Seidel and T.S. Rappaport, "914 MHz path loss prediction models for indoor wireless communications in multifloored buildings", IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, vol.40, no.2, pp.207-217, Feb. 1992.
[44] J. Yuan, J. Wei and G.X. Shen “comparison of optical modulation methods for RF Coil interlinks”, In Proceeding of the 14th Scientific Meeting and Exhibition for
Magnetic Resonance Technologists 14, pp. 784 (2006).
[45] R.A. Garnham and L.C. Blank,"100 dB optical path loss transmission system experiment employing two linear optoelectronic repeaters", Electronics Letters , vol.25, no.3, pp.179-180, 2 Feb. 1989.
[46] A. Chandra, A. Kumar and P. Chandra, "Comparative study of path losses from propagation measurements at 450 MHz, 900 MHz, 1.35 GHz and 1.89 GHz in the corridors of a multifloor laboratory-cum-office building", 1999, IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference, VTS 99- Fall 50th , pp.2272-2276, 1999.
[47] Li-Quan Wang, N.E. Evans, J.B. Burns, "Path loss enhancement in corridor serviced 2.3 GHz radio telemetry links", 1993, Proceedings of the 15th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, pp.1043-1044, 1993.
[48] G. Chen, Z. Xu, H. Ding and Sadler, “Path Loss Modeling and Performance Trade-off Study for Short- Range non-line-of-sight Ultraviolet Communications”, Optics Express, Vol. 17, Issue 5, pp. 3929-3940 (2009).
[49] S. O'Brien, H. Foulk, H. Gebretsadik, N. Frateschi, W.J. Choi, A.E. Bond, S. Robetson and R. Jambunathan, "Highly integrated 1.55 μm analog transmitter for high speed (15 GHz), high dynamic range analog transmission", 2004, IEEE International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, MWP'04, pp. 281- 284, 4-6 Oct. 2004.
[50] C. Cox, G.E. Betts and A.C. Yee, "Incrementally lossless, broad-bandwidth analog fiber-optic link", Proc. IEEE LEOS Summer Top. Meeting, pp.15 -16, 1990 , 23-25 Jul, 1990.
[51] Z. Jia, J. Yu and G. Chang, “Chirp- Managed Directly- Modulated DFB Laser” Recent Patents on Engineering 2007, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2007.
[52] E. Ackerman, D. Kasemset, S. Wanuga, D. Hogue and J. Komiak, "A high-gain directly modulated L-band microwave optical link," 1990, IEEE MTT-S International Microwave Symposium Digest, pp.153-155 vol.1, 8-10 May 1990.
[53] E. Ackerman, D. Kasemsei, S. Wanuga and S. Chinn, "High gain, wide dynamic range L-band externally modulated fibre optic link", Electronics Letters , vol.26, no.17, pp.1339-1341, 16 Aug. 1990.
[54] E.I. Ackerman,"The "effective" gains and noise Figures of individual components in an analog photonic link", 2003, Proceedings of International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, MWP 2003, pp. 369- 372, 10-12 Sep. 2003.
[56] L. Zhang, X. Hu, P. Cao, T. Wang and Y. Su, "A multiband radio over fiber system using one single-drive Mach-Zehnder modulator", 2010, Communications and Photonics Conference and Exhibition (ACP), pp.449-450, 8-12 Dec. 2010.
[57] V. Van, W.N. Herman and Ping-Tong Ho, "Linearized microring-loaded Mach-Zehnder modulator with RF gain", Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol.24, no.4, pp. 1850- 1854, April 2006.
[58] E.I. Ackerman and C. Cox, "The effect of a Mach-Zehnder modulator's traveling-wave electrode loss on a photonic link's noise Figure", 2003, Proceeding of International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, MWP 2003, pp. 321- 324, 10-12 Sept. 2003.
[59] S. Tzeng, H. Lu, C. Chen, and H Peng, “Externally modulated lightwave CATV transport system employing negative dispersion fiber”, IEICE Electronics Express, vol. 1, no. 11, pp. 287-29 (2004).
[60] Y. Shibata and T. Yasui, “Lossless Operation in InP Mach-Zehnder Modulator Monolithically Integrated with Semiconductor Optical Amplifier, Semiconductor Technologies”, Jan Grym (Ed.), ISBN: 978-953-307-080-3, InTech, 2010.
[61] C. Cox, L.M. Johnson, and G.E. Betts, "A theoretical and experimental comparison of directly and externally modulated fiber-optic links", 1989, IEEE MTT-S International Microwave Symposium Digest, pp.689-692, 13-15 Jun 1989.
[62] L. Zhang, X. Hu, P. Cao, T. Wang, and Y. Su, “A bidirectional radio over fiber system with multiband-signal generation using one single-drive MZM”, Opt Express. 14;19(6):5196-201, Mar. 2011.
[63] C. Cox, G. Betts, and L.M. Johnson, "An analytic and experimental comparison of direct and external modulation in analog fiber-optic links", IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, vol.38, no.5, pp.501-509, May. 1990.
[64] C. H. Cox, “Gain and noise Figure in analogue fiber-optic links”, Proc. Inst. Elect. Eng. pt. J, pp. 238–242, 1992.