簡易檢索 / 詳目顯示

研究生: 高小倩
Hsiao - Chien Kao
論文名稱: 佛教寺院建築現代化研究:以中臺禪寺、法門寺合十舍利塔個案為核心
A Study of the Development of Contemporary Monasteries :The Case Study on Chung Tai Chan Monastery and Namaste Dagoba
指導教授: 施植明
Chih-ming Shih
口試委員: 王惠君
Huey-Jiun Wang
王重平
C. P. Wang
顏名宏
Ming-Hung Yen
邱奕旭
I-Hsu Chiu
學位類別: 博士
Doctor
系所名稱: 設計學院 - 建築系
Department of Architecture
論文出版年: 2011
畢業學年度: 99
語文別: 英文
論文頁數: 107
中文關鍵詞: 寺院建築現代化李祖原中臺禪寺合十舍利塔
外文關鍵詞: Monasterial Architecture, Modernization
相關次數: 點閱:274下載:12
分享至:
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報
  • 佛教自印度傳入中國,早期寺院建築形式受印度佛寺影響,在唐朝時期即由「宮殿式」建築形式取代,是最早寺院中國化的時代,其亦對日本佛教寺院發生極大影響,目前尚存的唐代古寺(法隆寺、招提寺等),即是日本寺院中國化的體現;佛教在亞洲各地傳播,各國產生屬於地域性文化特徵的佛教形式,均視中國佛教為其起源,如:日本、韓國、海南島、越南等;臺灣亦屬於這個大東亞佛教圈。
    臺灣佛教由大陸閩南移民傳入臺灣,寺院也移植閩南式樣的建築形式;到日治時期,除移植極富日本色彩的佛寺建築形式外,也開展了臺灣建築近代化的發展,故研究臺灣傳統佛教寺院發展脈絡,中國與日本的影響均不容忽視。
    隨著現代化腳步往全球推展,現代建築運動的趨力伴隨著經濟與文化交流的龐大能量,在全世界擴散、累積,從現代化到全球化的發展進程,「建築現代化」課題成為每個國家、地區與文化圈中,建築專業領域關注的焦點,並以此來論述其各自的建築文化發展,以及現代化力量與本土化、地方傳統間的對話與折衝。
    故本研究設定佛教寺院建築類型,藉由檢視台灣當代佛教建築發展歷史向度的變遷,以李祖原建築師創作觀為例,以其中臺禪寺與中國西安法門寺合十舍利塔兩個作品,來探討建築現代化的課題。以「現代化」議題作為理解當代佛教寺院建築,從傳統到現代轉變的核心概念,一方面,企圖探討在現代的情境氛圍條件下,包含佛光山、十方禪堂等佛教寺院如何以「在地性」(或「臺灣性」)來建構具「臺灣性」的寺院建築論述與作品,以及如何由此來解讀其建築文化形式風格的轉化,及其承載的佛教教義,以期與教徒在信仰層次的對話。另一方面,透過同一位建築師在兩岸佛寺建築設計作品的比較與對話,試圖更廣泛而深入地思考現代性力量,在不同社會歷史情境中的建築生產,所可能發生的影響與作用。


    Following the development of global modernization and the flow of cultural and economic power, the trend of architectural modernization has spread worldwide and had a significant impact on the constructive culture in different regions. During the developmental shift from modernization to globalization, the topic of modernization has become the focus of the architectural field in every country, region, and cultural circle. Architectural modernization has been the basis for further exploration of original local cultures, and produced dialog and conflict alike over modernization, localization, and tradition.
    This study investigates the construction of Buddhist Monasteries that were constructed with modern architectural techniques. Rather than focusing on the modern architectural trends imported into Taiwan from Japan during the colonial period and later directly from the West, this study takes localized features as the point of departure for analyzing the unique design characteristics Buddhist monasteries have taken on during the course of modernization. It is shown that the impact of cultural globalization, provincial architecture has either implicitly or explicitly been developed into the mainstream via the inspiration of “outside” cultures. With respects to monastic architecture, the Chung Tai Chan Monastery, and the Namaste Dagoba designed by architect C. Y. Lee, stands out as an outstanding alternative formation of the modernized spirit of Buddhism in both Straits. As globalization continues to gain momentum, localization is emerging as a widespread reaction to cultural homogeneity, and the expression of a unique identity is taking on increasing importance for nations, societies, and religions. This study discussed the major trends of modernization techniques on Buddhist monasteries in Taiwan, namely classical Chinese modernization, Western modernism, and Postmodernism. How these trends are manifested on these Buddhist monasteries are compared and contrasted to demonstrate how modern Buddhist architectural techniques are exemplified in today’s Taiwan. At the same time, the authors expect to refer to comparative studies works designed by architect C. Y. Lee between Straits, to obtain an in-depth understanding of the possible influence of modernization on different societies and its historical roots.

    Contents --------------------------------------------------------------------- Abstract I Acknowledgments V Contents VII List of Illustrations and Tables IX List of Special Terms XIII Chapter 1 Introduction 1 1.1 Research Background 5 1.2 Research Method and Analytical Framework 7 1.3 Literature Review 10 Chapter 2 The Origins of Buddhist Monasterial building and its Transformation 25 2.1 The Origins of Buddhist Monasterial building: Stupa and Cave Temples 28 2.2 The Stylistic Features of Traditional Chinese architecture in Buddhist Monasteries: Corridors, Symmetry and Axial Layout 31 2.3 The Development and Transformation of Monastery Design in Taiwan (pre-1945) 38 2.4 The Development Trend of the Modernization of Chinese Monasteries Following the Cultural Revolution 42 2.5 A Brief Summary 48 Chapter 3 A Study of the Development of Contemporary Monasteries in Taiwan 49 3.1 The Development of Modern Architecture in Taiwan: A Brief Review 49 3.2 Case Studies: Three Monastery in Taiwan 53 Chapter 4 Chung Tai Chan Monastery and the Namaste Dagoba at Famen Temple 67 4.1 Practical Buddhist Architecture Philosophy of C. Y. Lee 67 4.2 The Modern Transformation of Monasteries in Taiwan: Chung Tai Chan Monastery 69 4.2.1 Three Categories of Analysis: Form, Function, Meaning 69 4.2.2 An Analysis of the Design Concept of Chung Tai Chan Monastery 70 4.3 The Rebirth of Famen Temple After the Cultural Revolution: The First Renovation Project After Chinese Economic Reform ---------------------------------------------------------------------------76 4.4 The Famen Temple Buddhist Cultural Scenic Area and the Namaste Dagoba 82 4.5 The Modernized Thinking behind the Architecture of Namaste Dagoba 85 Chapter 5 Conclusion:The Paradox of Modernized Buddhist Monasterial Architecture? 91 5.1 The Characteristics of Modernized Buddhist Monasterial Architecture 91 5.2 Theoretical Construction of Modern Buddhist Monastery: The Paradox of Modernized Buddhist Monastery Architecture 97 5.3 Suggestions and Directions of Future Research 100 References 101 Vita 107

    References
    -----------------------------------------------
    Althusser, Louis ‘Contradiction and Overdetermination, Translated’: by Ben Brewster, Penguin Press. (1962)
    Baizhang Whaihai. ‘Baizhang qinggui’, Translation by Hsieh, Chung-Kuang (814),Buddha’s light publishing.(814)
    Chen, Qing-Xiang, ‘The Study on Development of Chung Tai Chan Monastery when translation for traditional Buddhism’, Taiwan Architect Magazin,Vol.328, pp.68-71. (2002)
    Chen, Qing-Xiang. ‘Contemporary Buddhism constructs which reflected the Buddhism ecology’. Chue Feng Quarterly, Vol. 20, pp. 4-13. (1997)
    Chen, Yi-kai, ‘Professor Yang Yingfeng—Concurrently discusses the Buddhism statuary and the artistic creation inspiration’, Chue Feng Quarterly,Vol.35, pp. 4-21. (2002)
    Chinese Buddhism Meeting. The records of Taiwan Buddhism temple. Fo Guang Shan. (1997)
    Dai, Jian. The Preliminary Study on the Monastery of Zen Buddism, Ming Wen, Taipei. (1991).
    Fu, Chao Ching ‘National Complex in the Chinese Modern Architecture:China's Classical Restoring Ancient Ways Type and Trading Off type Modern Architecture before 1949’, Dandai, Vol. 23, pp.90-111, (1988).
    Fo Guang Shan ancestor service committee, ‘The chronicle of Fo Guang Shan originate 30 years’ (1997).
    Gao, Li-Ke,‘ In the reforming struggle of modernity ’,The 21st Century Comments, Vol. 88, pp. 26-32,(2005).
    Gao, Quan-xi, ’Cultural politics and the modernity question of’ truth, Si Xiang, Vol.3, pp.237-256, (2006).
    Giddens, Anthony, ‘The Contours of High Modernity’. Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Later Modern Age, California: Stanford, (1991)
    Gombrich, Ernst Hans Josef. The Uses of Images: Studies in the Social Function of Art and Visual Communication. London: Phaidon. (1999)
    Guo, Wei-Jei ‘To Make a Harmony Composition- Foreign Missionary and “Chinese Style” Architecture, 1911-1949’, China Scholarship, Vol.13, pp.73-78, (2003)
    Guo, Dai-Heng, ‘The first mountain of east—The country temple’, Beijing, Cultural relic publishing house,(2003).
    Hsia, Chu-Joe, ‘Building Colonial Modernity: Rewriting Histories of Architecture and Urbanism in the Colonial Taiwan ’, Taiwan: A Radical Quarterly in Social Studies, Vol.40, pp.47-82, (2002).
    Huang, Lan-Shiang, ‘The Thansformation and non-transformation of Buddism’, The Second times colonized the metropolis and the building:The native place culture with colonizes the culture》 International academic seminar,pp.4-1~4-44,Taipei , Institute of Taiwan History (2004).
    Hung, W. H., Wang, M. H., ‘The Modernization of Buddhist Architecture Forms’, International Conference on Buddhism Architectural Design and Development, pp.243-261(1998)
    Ito, Chuta, ‘Chinese history of architecture’, Translation by Chen, Qing-Quan, Taipei, Commercial Press (1967)
    Jameson, Fredric, ‘Postmodernism and Cultural Theories’, Lectures in China (Houxiandaizhuyi and Wenhualilun). Xi'an: Shanxi Teacher's University. Translation by Tang Xiaobing (1987). Reprinted in journals in Taiwan & Hong Kong, Hechih culture Co., Ltd., (1989)
    Jencks, Charles. The Post-modern Reader. London: Academy Editions Print. (1992).
    Jiang, Tsan-Teng, ’ The contemporary Buddhist temple construction's criticism datum and the province think’, Civilized exploration series , Vol.16, pp.115-122,(1999)
    Jiang, Tsan-Teng ,‘Research of the Taiwan Buddhism hundred year history ’, Taipei , Western Books(1996)
    Jiang, Tsan-Teng, ‘Extension and innovation-the modernized question of Taiwan Buddhism constructs’,Dialogue,Vol,11, pp.63-68,(1998)
    Lee, C. Y. & Partners Architects ‘Introduction of Chung Tai Chan Monastery’, Taiwan Architect Magazine, Vol. 328, pp.56–61, (2002)
    Lee, C. Y, ‘An Alternative Orientalism’, Taiwan Architect Magazine, pp.56-59,(2005)
    Li, Wei, and Hu, Chao-wen, ‘Ideology and the Exploration of Modernity on Chinese Architecture’ , Journal Of Huizhou University, Vol.29,pp.87-93(2009)
    Li, Ben-Hua, ‘Zhaogu Tengjin Yao Famen,The Famen Temple’,(2008)
    Lu, Chia-hsin,’The First Buddhism Monastery in Taiwan-Chu Hsi Temple’, Gu Gin Tan, Vol. 9 (1965).
    Liao,Shu-Chen, ‘The Budda view of Contemporary Buddhism and Religious Practice’,Master Thesis of Hsuan Chuang University(2002)
    Liu, Qi-Wan, ‘Buddhist temple of Qing Dynasty in Taiwan ’; Zhang, Man-Tao ed. Academic series of Modern Buddhism: Essay on Chinese Buddhism History/ The Volume of Taiwan Buddhism, pp.187-232, Taipei, Mahayana culture publishing house (1965)
    Markus, Thomas, A. ‘Buildings as Social Objects’, Companion to Contemporary Architectural Thought, London; New York: Routledge, (1993)
    Shi, Neng Rong, ‘An Investigation on the Vinaya’s Monastic Discipline, Chinese Monastic Regulations, and their Significance in the Present Sangha Order’, Chung-Hwa Institute of Buddhist Studies 36, Taipei, Dharma Drum Culture(2003)
    Shigeo, Kamada(かまた しげお, 鎌田茂雄), Translation by Zheng, Peng Nian, ‘Concise Chinese Buddhism history’,Sindian City:Gu-Feng Publishing House (1987)
    Sinha, Ajay J. ‘Architectural Invention in Sacred Structures: the Case of vesara Temples of Southern India’, Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians Vol.55, pp.382-99, (1996)
    Su, Gin-Djih, ‘Chinese Architecture, Past and Contemporary’, Hong Kong: The Sin Poh Amalgamated (H.K.) Ltd., (1964)
    Sun, Chuan Wen, A semiotic analysis of space and form in Chinese architecture, Taipei, (1995)
    Thomas, A. M.,‘Buildings as social objects’, in Ben Farmer and Hentie Louw(ed.) Companion to Contemporary Architectural Thought, New York: Routledge, (1993)
    Tang, Minrui (2003), ‘Buddhist art’, in Chung Tai Chan Monastery World (on line), http://www.ctworld.org.tw/chungtai/tour/b15.htm, accessed 21 June 2009.
    Tsai, Ing Wen, ‘Nationalism, Popular Sovereignty and Western Modernity’, A Journal for Philosophical Study of Public Affairs, Vol.3, pp.1-47, (2002)
    Ven. Hui-Yen, ’Early History of Buddhism in Taiwan’, Chung-Hwa Buddhist Journal,Vol.8, pp.273-314, Taipei, Chung-Hwa Institute of Buddhist Studies (1995)
    Venturi, Robert. Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture. The Museum of Modern Art Press, New York (1966)
    Wang, Chun-Long,‘The search of predicament and the favorable turn initially inTaiwan temple architecture’, Chue Feng quarterly ,Vol.19,pp.2-7,(1997)
    Wang, David Teh-Yu ‘Chung Tai Chan Monastery in the Context of Architectural Eclecticism’, Journal of Taipei Fine Arts Museum, Vol. 5, pp.61-87,(2002)
    Wang, Hui, ‘Contemporary Chinese Thoughts and the Question of Modernity’, Taiwan: A Radical Quarterly in Social Studies, Vol.37, pp.1-43(2000)
    Wang, Yuan Yi, ‘A View of Chinese Modernity’, Bulletin of the Department of History of National Taiwan University,Vol.28,pp.249-274(2001),
    Weng, Ming Hung, ‘An Elementary Study on the Hierarchical Bases of Fo Guang Shan Friary in its Middle Parish of Taiwan’, Master Theses, Department of Architecture, Taichung, Taiwan: Tunghai University (2000)
    Wong, Kwok-Kui, ‘Can Kant’s Concept of Time in the First Critique Answer Augustine’s Question?’, The National Chengchi University Philosophical Journal, Vol.16, pp. 1-30 (2006)
    Xu, Gui-Ling、Situ, Shangji, ’Cultural buddhist temple’, Beijing, The Ethnic Publishing House(2005)
    Xiao, Mo, ‘The research of Dunhuang constructs’, Beijing, Cultural relic publishing house (1989)
    Yang, Han-Hen, ‘The Dialogue between Tradition and Modernity---A Research of the Post-War Buddhist Monasteries’, In Hsinchu District, Taiwan, Tainan (2005)
    Yang, Han-Yang , ‘The Dialogue between Tradition and Modernity---A Research of the Post-War Buddhist Monasteries in Hsinchu District’, Taiwan; Master of National Cheng Kung University
    Yan, S. H, ‘Early History of Buddhism in Taiwan’, Chung-Hwa Buddhist Journal, Vol.8, pp.273-314, (1995)
    Yeh, Tin-gia, ‘The Origin of Taiwanese Zhaijiao’, Zhang, Man-Tao ed. Academic series of Modern Buddhism: Essay on Chinese Buddhism History/ The Volume of Taiwan Buddhism, pp.363-372, Taipei: Mahayana Press. (1979)
    Yi, Zhai, ‘Lee,C.Y. makes the life city—Modern traveler of annotation beauty of architectural art in the imperial sacrifices are pleased’, National spirit, pp.64-67,(2007)
    Yu, Hsiou-min , ‘Constructing Ceremonial Holy Space in Buddhism--The Application of Ronald L. Grimes' Ceremonial Depiction in the Field Studies ’,Hsuan Chuang Journal of Buddhism,Vol.1,pp.53-94,(2004)
    Zhang, Man-Tao, ‘Academic series of Modern Buddhism: Essay on Chinese Buddhism History/ The Volume of Taiwan Buddhism’, pp.233-254, Taipei, Mahayana culture publishing house (1979)
    Zhang, Man-Tao, ‘North garden guest house and Kaiyuan Temple’, Zhang, Man-Tao ed. Academic series of Modern Buddhism: Essay on Chinese Buddhism History/ The Volume of Taiwan Buddhism, pp.269-320, Taipei, Mahayana culture publishing house (1979)
    Zhi, Hai, ‘Monastic rules for Buddhists Initially searches’, Wu Yan-Sheng ed., Chinese imperial sacrifices study,Vol.1, Beijing, China Publishing House,(2002)
    Zeng, Cheng-De、Wu, Guang-Ting, ‘International characteristic vs. Local-Taiwan building sidelight in the past 30 years’, History, pp.108-115.

    QR CODE